The Great Collectibles

What collectors chase — and what gets faked.

  1. 07

    Art — The Foremost Collectible in the World

    The highest price ever paid for any collectible was nearly half a billion dollars — for a single Leonardo.

  2. 08

    Historical Manuscripts — “The Thoughts of Mankind”

    Leonardo’s handwritten codex sold at Sotheby’s for $30 million — to Bill Gates, an inventor himself.

  3. 09

    Coin Collecting — The Catch-22

    The 1933 Double Eagle — struck the year gold was banned — recently sold for nearly $20 million.

  4. 10

    Gun Collecting — The Allure of Old Guns

    America’s most popular collectible — and a forger can turn a common gun into a rare one in an afternoon.

  5. 11

    American Swords (1776–1865)

    Napoleon’s presentation sword sold in Paris in 2025 for $5 million. The sword is the most personal of weapons.

  6. 12

    American Flags (1700–2000)

    The four Tarleton Revolutionary War flags sold at Sotheby’s for $17 million.

  7. 13

    The American Civil War (1860–1865)

    The most-faked field in American collecting — and the math has never worked.

  8. 14

    The American Indian (1500–1900)

    The finest beadwork in the history of mankind — and a thriving trade in fakes.

  9. 15

    The American West (1500–2000)

    Manifest Destiny, gold rushes, and outlaws — alongside the garage-built “relics” that follow them.

  10. 16

    World War II (1933–1945)

    The Greatest Generation — and the medals, souvenirs, and documents that get forged.

How the Trade Works — and How It’s Gamed

Auctions, banks, insurers, and the law.

  1. 01

    Auction Companies — “The Big Back Door”

    A year inside an auction house: $30 million in consignments, a commission never paid, and the back-door games.

  2. 02

    Bank Loans & Liens — “Loan to Own”

    A $25,000 painting, a $650,000 appraisal, a $400,000 loan — and a $1 million fraud.

  3. 03

    Insurance Frauds — “Lightning”

    Insurance fraud in collectibles is an easy crime to commit. All you need is a patsy.

  4. 04

    Replevin & Repatriation — “It’s Mine, Not Yours”

    It begins with a phone call: a claim that what you own really belongs to a government, a country, or someone else.

  5. 05

    Estate Planning — The Future of Your Collection

    Thomas Jefferson did his own — and here is why your inventory should never go online.

  6. 06

    Tax Donation — To Your Favorite Museum

    Donate to a museum and keep your name in perpetuity — without inviting an IRS problem.

Reflections

Why it was written — and who got it right.

  1. 17

    Epilogue — Why I Published This Guidebook

    “I’m mad as hell, and I’m not going to take it anymore.” Everything in this book is real — and it happened to me.

  2. 18

    Addendum — Afterthoughts & the Psychology of Collecting

    Hard-won reflections on why we collect, and how to keep doing it with your eyes open.

  3. 19

    Great Collectors & the Good Guys

    Not everyone in this trade is a scoundrel. The greatest American collector built his own Western town.

  4. 20

    Glossary — The Language of Collecting

    A working vocabulary for buyers, sellers, and heirs — so the next scoundrel can’t hide behind the jargon.