Gary Hendershott, appraiser and author of Fakes & Scoundrels
Gary Hendershott · Arkansas

A self-taught appraiser who learned the trade from inside it.

Gary Hendershott began collecting in 1972, age nine, with a stamp album his grandfather had set aside. By high school Gary was buying coins; by the end of his first decade in the trade, he had moved into Native American artifacts, fine art, and the historical American documents that would become his life's work.

Today, after five decades inside the American collectibles market, Gary Hendershott brings his appraisal practice to bear on disputed provenance, questioned signatures, and the kind of forgery work that ends careers and empties estates. Gary has handled some of the most significant pieces of American material culture in private hands — and watched, again and again, as the trade looked the other way.

Fakes & Scoundrels is the book Gary Hendershott says nobody else in the business was willing to write — a twelve-chapter investigation of the fakes, the scoundrels, and the polite machinery that keeps them both in business.

Selected Acquisitions & Authentications

Forty years on the record.

Fine Art

  • Gilbert Stuart's Athenaeum portrait of George Washington (acquired)
  • Charles Willson Peale, signed period work (acquired and authenticated)
  • Court-witness on contested portrait attribution, 1990s

Historical Documents

  • Washington's 22-page signed "Fair Reading" speech (authenticated, acquired)
  • Period correspondence from the Continental Congress era
  • Provenance review for several presidential libraries

Militaria & Civil War

  • Confederate edged weapons (40+ years of authentication work)
  • Field cannon authentication and restoration consulting
  • Re-stamped firearms detection & expert testimony

Native American & Pre-Columbian

  • Authentication and provenance review for major auction consignments
  • Detection work on contemporary forgery rings (1990s – present)
  • Pre-Columbian attribution under disputed export histories
Career Timeline

Fifty years of Gary Hendershott on the record.

1972
Begins collecting at age nine with an inherited stamp album. Moves into coins within two years.
1980s
Opens his first appraisal practice in Arkansas. Early work concentrates on rare coins and Confederate militaria.
1990s
Takes on fine-art authentication and historical documents. Provides court-witness testimony on contested portrait attribution and questioned signatures.
2000s
Handles Gilbert Stuart's Athenaeum portrait of George Washington. Authenticates Washington's 22-page signed "Fair Reading" speech. Expands detection work on contemporary forgery rings.
2010s
Provenance review for presidential libraries and major auction consignments. Growing focus on Pre-Columbian and Native American attribution under disputed export histories.
2020s
Begins drafting Fakes & Scoundrels — the twelve-chapter case file Gary Hendershott says the trade has politely avoided publishing for forty years.
2026
Fakes & Scoundrels published. Available at Barnes & Noble.
Frequently Asked Questions

About Gary Hendershott.

Who is Gary Hendershott?

Gary Hendershott is an American appraiser, collector, and author with more than fifty years of experience inside the US collectibles trade. He is the author of Fakes & Scoundrels, the first insider account of fraud, forgery, and deception in the American collectibles market.

What does Gary Hendershott appraise?

Gary Hendershott appraises American historical documents, Civil War and Confederate militaria, fine art, rare coins, Native American and Pre-Columbian artifacts, and questioned-provenance items. His practice focuses on authentication, provenance research, and forgery detection.

What book did Gary Hendershott write?

Gary Hendershott is the author of Fakes & Scoundrels, a twelve-chapter investigation of fraud across the American collectibles trade. The book is available at Barnes & Noble (ISBN 9798295830488).

Where is Gary Hendershott based?

Gary Hendershott is based in Arkansas, where he has run an appraisal practice for more than four decades.

What are Gary Hendershott's most notable acquisitions?

Gary Hendershott has handled Gilbert Stuart's Athenaeum portrait of George Washington and authenticated Washington's 22-page signed "Fair Reading" speech, among other significant pieces of American material culture.

How do I contact Gary Hendershott?

For press, bulk orders, signed copies, and appraisal inquiries, use the contact form.

Beyond the Book

More from Gary Hendershott.

Five decades of collecting, two more projects worth your time — an archive of the history Gary Hendershott has handled, and the true story he spent fifteen years chasing.

The Archive · Americana

Gary Hendershott: The History

A half-century collecting American history — personal effects tied to George Washington, Robert E. Lee, and Nathan Bedford Forrest, working relationships with more than twenty museums, and the Amazon tribal art collection Gary donated to Tulane University in 2014. His portfolio site also keeps a journal of his research.

Visit the history archive
Also by the Author

B-4112: The Blue Diamonds

Gary Hendershott's other book: the true account of Holocaust survivor Richard Friedemann — Auschwitz prisoner B-4112 — whose family buried more than a hundred rare blue diamonds beneath a Ukrainian church before the Nazi occupation, and the fifteen-year quest to recover them.

Read about B-4112
"I have been the dealer. I have been the consignor. I have been the appraiser called in after the fact. There is no part of this trade I have not seen from the inside. That is precisely why I can write this book — and why nobody else has." Gary Hendershott